Hunting for a record-book buck


The author, left, measures a whitetail rack with official scorer James McGregor.
(Photo by John Bennett.)

Hunting is not often about spectacular wallhanging racks… but, in some cases it is.

Even the most ardent meat hunters amongst us have fantasized about placing a tag on a major record-book whitetail, perhaps even a new planet record. Then there are these hunters who actively target bucks that will make the record-book minimums and will not settle for something much less.

Regardless of exactly where you fall in this spectrum, understanding a bit about how record-maintaining systems operate, what constitutes a “book buck,” and what to appear for in the field, can only enhance your probabilities of attaining deer-hunting immortality.

A bit of history

The recording of measurements started in Africa in the late 1800s and was initial applied to North American major game by the Boone and Crockett Club (B&C) in 1932. In 1950, B&C produced and copyrighted a detailed scoring technique which formed the basis for all subsequent measuring systems and which is nonetheless the most extensively utilized currently.

The Pope & Young Club (P&Y) was formed a couple of years later and serves as the official repository or records of bow-harvested North American major game, excluding crossbows, applying the B&C scoring technique.

The Foundation for the Recognition of Ontario Wildlife (FROW) was formed in 1989 and utilizes the similar B&C scoring technique, but records only major game and turkeys harvested in Ontario.

Two systems emerged

Ultimately, two more scoring systems emerged: an all-inclusive technique adopted by Safari Club International (SCI) in 1977 for their planet-wide record maintaining and a equivalent complete-credit scoring technique taken on by Buckmasters in the mid-1990s. Despite the fact that each of these systems use the similar measuring procedures as B&C, there are important variations in what they consist of in their scoring.

All of these systems and the organizations that use them share a philosophy of honouring the animal when recognizing the achievement of the hunter for posterity. The information collected is shared with interested wildlife agencies, and offers insight into the previous and present management, well being, and trends of North America’s wildlife populations.

The scoring systems

Boone and Crockett and Foundation for the Recognition of Ontario Wildlife

The B&C technique is primarily based on what its creators felt had been the perfect specimens of every single species. For whitetails, that contains the length of every single major beam and its circumference at 4 locations the length of every single tine and the inside spread, with separate categories for Standard and Non-Standard specimens. Measurements are completed to the nearest eighth of an inch.

As the system’s creators saw it as a very desirable characteristic, B&C locations heavy emphasis on symmetry, and penalizes antler development that is abnormal or non-symmetrical. For instance, if a buck’s proper brow tine is six inches extended but the left is only 4 inches, a two-inch deduction is produced for that distinction, efficiently nullifying the more length of the longer point.

Similarly, while the Non-Standard category adds rather than deducts for abnormal points, they have to be symmetrical, or they will outcome in a deduction. Criticism of this technique led to the creation of the SCI and Buckmasters systems.

Pope & Young Club

P&Y utilizes the B&C technique, but the minimum scores essential for entry in their record book is decrease (see sidebar “What it requires: minimum scores”), owing to the higher level of difficulty of harvesting a trophy buck with a bow. In addition, P&Y accepts racks in velvet, when B&C needs that they be stripped ahead of scoring.


The creator of the Buckmasters Complete Credit Scoring Program felt that, with so significantly all-natural variation in whitetail racks, a buck need to be provided consideration for every single inch of antler he grew, without having conforming to an perfect of excellent symmetry.

As such, the Buckmasters technique has no deductions. Constant with the philosophy of providing credit for all antler development, it does not call for a minimum drying period, as other systems do, ahead of a rack can be officially scored. This eliminates any shrinkage issue.

What could possibly look contradictory even though, is that the Buckmasters technique does not count inside spread, as that is observed as a measure of air, not antler. The trade-off is that it makes it possible for inclusion of skulls that have been split for what ever explanation, which B&C does not.

Buckmasters classifies racks into 4 categories: Ideal, Standard, Semi-Irregular, or Irregular, and straightforward math determines which applies. The entry minimums differ for gun or bow, but are constant across the 4 categories.

Safari Club International

SCI’s technique is equivalent to Buckmasters in that it does not penalize for abnormalities or asymmetry. The big distinction is that SCI contains inside spread. And, SCI is the only record book that has much more than one particular geographic classification for whitetails, with Ontario falling into the Northeastern group.

Equivalent to B&C, SCI has categories for Standard and Non-Standard, with the option getting up to the hunter (while a minimum of three% of non-standard development is essential for the Non-Standard category). SCI only needs a mandatory drying period for prospective leading-20 specimens.

What’s in a score?

Regardless of the technique, there are a quantity of components that go into generating a record-book whitetail rack, but they usually boil down to width, height, mass, and quantity of points. And surprisingly, even amongst planet-class specimens, couple of bucks have it all.

record book bucks

If you appear at the present B&C planet record Standard, the Milo Hanson buck taken in Saskatchewan in 1993, you will promptly notice the amazing width, with an inside spread of 27 two/eight inches. The subsequent factor you will notice is the impressive height of its 14 total points. But its mass? Just 5 inches in circumference at the base of the left antler, and even much less on the proper the major beams naturally get a bit thinner closer to the ends. So even the extended-standing planet record Standard whitetail is only typical when it comes to antler mass.

What’s most crucial?

After we accept that we are not probably to see a whitetail possessing equal measures of all these qualities, the query becomes, which of these qualities is most crucial for generating the book?

According to B&C, the single most crucial element is major beam length. Primarily based on all bucks incorporated in the Standard category in their all-time records book, length of major beam accounts for about 30% of the total scores. In other words, without having major beams of at least 24 inches in length, it is incredibly challenging for a buck to make the B&C minimum.

Following major beam length, the most crucial person elements are inside spread, length of second points, and length of third points, every single of which accounts for, on typical, 12% of the final score.

Nevertheless, while length contribution ranges from a low of only six% for initial points to a higher of 12% for seconds and thirds, taken in the aggregate, the element of “height” general can be close to 40%.

Similarly, for mass, circumference measurements only account for four% to six% every single, but provided that there are 4 utilized on every single side, they account for about 20% in total.

Symmetry important

As pointed out, symmetry is important for a B&C entry, as a hunter from Wisconsin discovered the challenging way practically a decade ago. He harvested an amazing buck that was initial believed to be the new planet-record Standard. Nevertheless, two points on the buck’s proper beam had been deemed to be “abnormal,” resulting in important deductions that place the buck effectively under that, even in the Non-Standard category.

As Glenn Hisey, director of records for P&Y told me not too long ago, “Sometimes it is not so significantly about how major a buck’s rack is, but how it compares to the perfect as determined by the creators of the scoring technique.”

Offered that Buckmasters does not count inside spread, the relative influence of every single of the other elements goes up correspondingly. Similarly, given that neither Buckmasters nor SCI deduct for abnormal points or asymmetry, the relative significance of length of points, or general “height,” is enhanced below these scoring systems.

What it requires

To definitely recognize what a buck requires to make the book, I went straight to the people today who hold the records.

record book bucks

Keith Balfourd is Director of Advertising and marketing for B&C. “Length is king when it comes to scoring a whitetail, so tines and beams matter the most,” he provided. “Narrow but tall trumps wide and quick every single time. If he’s each wide and tall, do not hesitate,” he added.

Closer to property, I asked Paul Beasley, Records Chairman of FROW, for his guidance to assist establish if the buck in your sights has record-book prospective. “To make the FROW minimum as a 10-pointer, at least two points on every single side have to be at least eight inches in height for an eight-pointer, at least two points on every single side have to be at least 10 inches in height. In either case, his inside spread have to be at least as wide as the recommendations of his ears when they’re straight out in a forward-facing position,” he advised.

From a bowhunter’s point of view, Glenn Hisey of P&Y provided this rapid field tip. “If the buck’s weaker side has at least 20 inches of points sticking up from the major beam (but not which includes the major beam), he’ll almost certainly make P&Y, assuming typical major beams and inside spread.”

With a somewhat decrease minimum score essential for entry into their record book, Mike Handley, trophy chairman for Buckmasters, provided this guidance, “Look for at least eight points, with decent brows, seconds, and thirds. If he’s improved than typical, he’ll almost certainly make it, when typical 10-pointers will usually make it.”

In the field

Regrettably reside whitetail bucks do not have measuring tapes strapped to their racks and they hardly ever stand about extended sufficient to give you time to size them up. We generally make snap judgements in the field as to regardless of whether a buck is a “Booner” or not. Nevertheless, we can use a couple of physical attributes as recommendations for field judging.

James McGregor is a taxidermist with Sophisticated Taxidermy in Caledon, and an official scorer for FROW. He’s measured hundreds if not thousands of bucks. According to James, the ears of an Ontario buck are ordinarily about seven inches in length, when his face is about 5 inches wide involving the ears. If you get a excellent head-on appear at a buck, these two measurements can give you a quite excellent judge of his inside spread, which you will want to beat least to the recommendations of his ears, or about 19 inches.

record book bucks

A buck’s ears are also ordinarily 3-and-a-half to 4 inches in vertical height at their tallest point the longest need to be at least 10 inches and the shortest at least 5 inches, or just longer than the height of his ears.

Appear for the beams to attain to the tip of the nose or beyond when viewed profile, as the distance from the eyes to nose is ordinarily seven to eight inches. This assists gauge at least the front-sweeping portion.

Lastly, for mass, it is usually accepted that the circumference of a whitetail’s eyeball is about 4 inches, so appear for a buck with bases that exceed the size of his eyeballs, or about the size of his outer eye location.

Judging a score

As with so a lot of other issues in life, practice is important to becoming a excellent judge of score. Completely study the score charts for every single record-maintaining organization that interests you, and then test oneself by estimating and then measuring as a lot of mounted heads or bucks taken by other hunters in camp as attainable. More than time, you will sharpen your field-judging capabilities.

To some, a trophy is all in the eye of the beholder. To other folks, it is an objective common as defined by a record-maintaining organization. Becoming familiar with their guidelines and procedures will add a new element to your deer-hunting enjoyment, and may well even assist you join the exclusive club of record holders one particular day.

What it requires: minimum scores

Initially published in the Ontario OUT of DOORS 2015-2016 Hunting Annual.

For much more hunting stories, click right here

For much more major game stories, click right here


Latest posts